Age-old real estate strategy raises fair housing, affordability concerns

Posted

Pocket listings, also known as private listings or exclusive listings, are getting more popular as ownership of real estate companies is consolidated. Several states and both houses of Congress are now taking a look at the controversial practice. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

The time-honored practice of allowing real estate agents to keep some listings private and determine which homes potential buyers see is facing pushback as the industry becomes more consolidated. Privately held listings, which are not advertised publicly, affect affordability, allow agents to engage in racial discrimination, and render home sale data used by appraisers incomplete, say critics. 

Private listings, also known as pocket or exclusive listings, are properties that are kept off the Multiple Listing Service, the database that is the source for houses and condominiums listed for sale on platforms such as Zillow and Redfin. Instead of being available to the public, the listings are known only to select agents and their colleagues. 

Pocket listings are getting more popular as ownership of real estate companies is consolidated.

This year, Compass Inc. paid $1.6 billion to acquire Anywhere Real Estate, which owns  national brands such as Coldwell Banker, Century 21, Sotheby’s, ERA, and Better Homes and Gardens.

Critics contend the practice allows agents to ‘double-end’ more of their transactions – earning a commission from the buyer and seller by keeping the transaction within the brokerage. 

A Consumer Policy Center analysis found that 41% of Compass’s transactions in Washington, D.C. were double-ended deals. 

Compass contends multiple listing services are the problem. Last week, it filed 15 antitrust lawsuits against MLS in eight states. 

Flouting the rules?

The National Association of REALTORS®’ Clear Cooperation Policy, adopted in 2020, requires a broker to enter a listing in the MLS within one business day of advertising it publicly. 

The policy states “significant growth in the use of pocket listings and misuse of various limited exposure marketing tactics” are to the “disadvantage of homebuyers and sellers,” and “generally have been perceived as benefitting the listing firm more than the client.”

Nevada REALTORS®, the state association that has until now spoken for local groups, says the rules are flexible.

“MLS listing requirements vary based on the circumstances of the listing and the policies established by each individual MLS,” association consultant Julie Walburn of Red Rock Strategies said via email.

Real estate experts say association rules are no longer sufficient to protect consumers. Some are advocating for legislation. 

Nevada law does not regulate private listing networks. 

Three states – Wisconsin, Connecticut, and New York – have passed laws requiring that sellers sign notarized disclosures acknowledging they are aware that their home won’t be advertised publicly for sale.  

Washington’s law prohibits private listings except in exceptional cases to protect an individual’s health or safety. 

“Nevada can do the same,” says Geoff Lavell of The Brokerage in Las Vegas. “Privacy calls for withholding an address or photos. It does not require that only one company’s clients may buy the home.”

Nevada REALTORS®, which generally conducts policy campaigns for Nevada real estate associations, is wary of enacting laws regulating private listings.

“Nevada’s real estate licensing laws establish enforceable duties for licensed professionals, including disclosure obligations, reasonable skill and care, and accountability to the consumers they represent,” NVR CEO Tiffany Banks said via email. “Those protections remain in place regardless of how a property is marketed or whether an MLS policy is challenged.”

George Pickard, CEO of the Northern Nevada Regional Multiple Listing Service says the organization, which is owned by Sierra Nevada REALTORS®, has hired its own lobbyist for the first time and is hoping the Nevada Legislature will take up the issue when it meets in February. 

He says while not perfect, his organization is more in line with the Washington state legislation.

“I think the most important part is that there’s a conversation happening about the issues posed by private listing networks to consumers, and that the MLS perspective is represented in those conversations,” he said. 

Pickard says no lawmaker has yet agreed to sponsor the legislation. 

Las Vegas REALTORS® did not respond to a request for comment. 

Lavell contends that a buyer’s ability to find an unadvertised home requires them to “hire the ‘right’ brokerage. That is a fair housing problem, a pricing problem and a market power problem.”

Private sales, Lavell says, deny small brokerages the level playing field that the MLS provides. Agents tend to flee for the larger companies “because that’s where the action is.”

The lack of competition results in higher costs for buyers. Large firms, he says, are unlikely to offer the discounted commissions that are common among smaller brokers. 

Large firms, however, can afford to incentivize agents to keep deals within the brokerage. 

Compass, according to the Consumer Policy Center, has a new program that offers any Compass agent a 10% commission if the referral of a seller or buyer to another Compass agent results in a sale.

While agents benefit from the arrangements, sellers are often left holding the bag. Private listings tend to sell for less than properties advertised on the MLS, say experts. 

Research from Zillow found that homes sold without being advertised on the MLS reaped 1.5% less than comparable homes that were listed, amounting to about $4,975 lost to the seller per transaction. 

Pickard says NNRMLS research indicates the difference can be as much as 17%. 

Additionally, private listings reduce the pool of available homes to buyers.

“A buyer on a tight budget needs to see every home in her price range,” says Lavell. When homes are hidden in private listing networks, choices are limited to what’s available to the agent.

The practice also tends to accelerate white flight – the migration of white people from ethnically diverse urban areas to suburbs – by steering buyers to properties in predominantly white neighborhoods.

Another study by Zillow found that homes in predominantly white neighborhoods were more than two times as likely to be in a private listing network as homes in urban areas.

“The growing acceptance of private listing networks by powerful real estate interests signals a shift in how the market operates, with selective access becoming a central feature rather than an exception,” Derrick Johnson, president of the NAACP, wrote in August.

Appraisers and lenders rely on public sales data to justify home prices. The dearth of data resulting from private listings – such as the number of days on the market and price changes – dilute that history, says Lavell. Prices, he says, “get harder to trust” as a result. 

“Public accountability suffers,” he adds. “Researchers, fair housing testers and reporters use open listing data to spot discrimination. They cannot audit what they cannot see.”

Both houses of Congress are now taking a look at the controversial practice.

“Nevada REALTORS® recognizes the significant value of the MLS in promoting transparency and broad market exposure,” says a statement from the association. “Equally important is ensuring that consumers receive accurate information, understand their options, and can make informed decisions when buying or selling a home.”

Proposed legislation, NVR says, “should be evaluated carefully, with a clear understanding of existing protections, demonstrated consumer needs, and potential unintended consequences, including potential antitrust implications.”

Housing, Compass In. Realtors, Zillow